English College

are detention effective? explain your thinking

Answers

Answer 1
Detention aims to make a discipline among the students who break rules and policies in school. 

It is been said that if a student violates or breaches a policy or rule must be taken for such disciplinary action as it would serve as a consequence for a certain undesirable act. It would be considered that detention instills self-realization that is beneficial to the student's development and learning.


Answer 2
Final answer:

The effectiveness of detention as a discipline strategy is debatable, with evidence suggesting that rehabilitative measures and alternatives such as education and community service may be more effective in reducing recidivism and fostering positive societal reintegration.

Explanation:

The effectiveness of detention as a disciplinary measure is a complex issue with varied perspectives and outcomes. The idea of detention, whether in schools for disciplining students or in the broader context of the criminal justice system for containing individuals, often sparks debate regarding its effectiveness in achieving reform and preventing future offenses. Supreme Court Justice Warren Burger highlighted a critical point over thirty years ago, emphasizing that merely confining offenders without efforts to change them is an 'expensive folly' with only short-term benefits. The fundamental goal behind such punitive measures should be the rehabilitation of the individual, aiming at reducing recidivism and fostering a safer society.

Research and examples from different countries suggest that alternatives to detention, such as education, probation, and community service, could be more effective in addressing the root causes of the behavior and helping individuals reintegrate into society more positively. For instance, studies indicate that for juveniles, incarceration is often counterproductive, reducing their chances of returning to school and thereby increasing the likelihood of future offenses. Similarly, the approaches seen in Western European nations like Denmark and the Netherlands, which focus on rehabilitation and alternatives to imprisonment, may offer valuable lessons in treating offenders more humanely and effectively.

Related Questions

Other Questions
The budget for a film production includes the following employee pay scales: $15,000 for each technical crew member (e.g. camera, lighting, sound), and $10,000 for each support staff (e.g., drivers, craft services, production assistants). A minimum of 20 employees is needed, but the locations can accommodate a maximum of 50 people. There must be at least 12 technical crew members to shoot the film, and there must be at least half as many crew members as support staff. Which combination of employees will minimize the cost, and what is the minimum feasible cost? What is the measure of angle AXB ) a young woman comes into the clinic complaining of itchy, red skin and swelling on her arms and legs. she had not been in any parks or wooded areas recently, but she had been shopping. a blood sample reveals elevated levels of granulocytes. what treatment is the physician likely to prescribe at this point? HELP WILLMARK BRAINLIEST.!!!! Who believed that the primary role of government should be to protect the majority of citizens from the excesses of greedy robber barons? Twenty-eight-year-old melissa is a research psychologist. she is known for her creative research problem solving and the ability to abstractly interpret research data. melissa is demonstrating: What is 44,816 rounded to the nearest hundred The stage of the cell cycle during which dna replicates is called _______. What is the term for the manner in which religions arise and change through contact with other cultures and religions? Describe an example of how necessity brings about technological change? Help Yaya ASAP PleaseJessica and Marcus each earn the same amount of money every week mowing lawns. Jessica saves 50% of her money and Marcus saves 1/4 of his money.Which statement is correct?A.Marcus saves 4/5 as much money as Jessica.B.Jessica saves 4/5 as much money as Marcus.C.Marcus saves twice as much money as Jessica.D.Jessica saves twice as much money as Marcus. To what extent does pleurozium affect nitrogen availability in northern forests of different successional ages By 1675, both the english and spanish had established colonies along the atlantic coast. a. True b. False A painter is paid 11 dollars per hour and can paint 8 m^2 with a roller in this time. renting a spray gun costs 5 dollars for each hour of use, and the painter can paint 20 m^2 per hour with the spray gun. it takes 1/2 an hour for the painter to clean up after using the roller, but 1 hour using the spray gun. you must pay the painter for her time and you must also pay for renting the spray gun for the total amount of time (including clean up) the spray gun was needed. how much money do you save by using the spray gun on a paint job that involves painting 40 m^2. list three outdoor safety tips and two fire safety and prevention guidelines Brandon rode his bike 90% of the distance that Carlee did this week. He rode 58.5 miles. How many miles did Carlee ride? What is the purpose of the "dissenting opinion" of the Supreme Court? Harriet made a list of all her monthly expenses. What is Harriets total cost for housing in a month?eating out = $40cell phone bill = $55rent = $370car insurance = $48groceries = $160renters insurance = $27gas = $60Total Housing=$______ Identify the organelles in the cell to the right.A B C D E F What are the slope and the y-intercept of the line T=14N+40 Steam Workshop Downloader